FOOT CARE

5 BEST INSOLES FOR PLANTAR FASCIITIS

Compare 5 popular insoles for arch support, cushioning, comfort, and everyday use.


Finding the right insole for plantar fasciitis can be overwhelming. We compared five popular options based on arch support, cushioning, comfort, fit, and intended use to help you narrow down your choices.


 


Updated: October 2026

QUICK COMPARISON

PowerStep Pinnacle

Dr. Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis

PowerStep Pinnacle

Orthotic insoles for arch support and everyday foot comfort

Best for: Everyday foot & arch support
Structured arch support with cushioning for everyday footwear.

Superfeet Green

Dr. Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis

PowerStep Pinnacle

Green orthotic insoles with firm arch support and contoured heel cushioning

Best for: Firmer arch support
A structured option for people who prefer a firmer support feel.

Dr. Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis

Dr. Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis

Dr. Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis

Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers
A plantar-fasciitis-focused option with cushioning for everyday use.

WalkHero

Dr. Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis

WalkHero orthotic insoles with arch support and cushioning for everyday foot comfort

Best for: Structured arch support and cushioning at a budget-friendly price.

Spenco Total Support Max

Spenco Total Support Max insoles with structured arch support, heel cushioning and forefoot comfort

Best for: Support + forefoot comfort
Structured arch support with additional cushioning and forefoot support.
 

How to Choose

What matters most:
Consider arch support, cushioning, shoe space, activity level, fit and overall comfort.

🏆 FEATURED PICK: POWERSTEP PINNACLE INSOLES

PowerStep Pinnacle orthotic insoles for arch support and everyday foot comfort

What makes it worth considering?

The PowerStep Pinnacle combines structured arch support with cushioning for everyday footwear.

Why consider it?


• Structured arch support
• Deep heel cradle
• Dual-layer cushioning
• Designed for everyday footwear
• Available in multiple sizes
• Designed for people seeking additional arch and heel support


Potential drawback

The structured design may feel different from a soft, cushion-only insole. Some shoes may also feel tighter because the insole takes up additional space.

Best suited for

People looking for a balance between arch support and cushioning for everyday walking, work, or casual footwear.

#CommissionsEarned

2. SUPERFEET GREEN INSOLES

Green orthotic insoles with firm arch support and contoured heel cushioning

What makes it worth considering?

Superfeet Green offers a firm, structured design for people looking for substantial arch support in roomy footwear.

Why consider it?

• Firm, structured support
• High-profile design
• Deep heel cup
• Full-length insole
• Designed for roomy footwear
• Suitable for everyday and active use


Potential drawback

The firm, high-profile design may feel too rigid for people who prefer softer cushioning, and it may not fit well in low-volume or tighter shoes.

Best suited for

People who prefer firmer arch support and have shoes with enough room for a higher-profile insole.

#CommissionsEarned

3. DR. SCHOLL'S PLANTAR FASCIITIS ORTHOTICS

Dr. Scholl’s plantar fasciitis orthotic insoles for arch support and everyday foot comfort

What makes it worth considering?

Dr. Scholl’s Plantar Fasciitis Orthotics offer an accessible option for shoppers looking for added heel cushioning and everyday arch support.

Why consider it?

• Designed with plantar fasciitis in mind
• Added heel cushioning
• Arch support for everyday use
• Easy to use in compatible footwear
• Widely available 


Potential drawback

People who prefer very firm or highly structured arch support may find this design less supportive than more rigid orthotic options.

Best suited for

People looking for an accessible, easy-to-use option that combines everyday cushioning with additional heel and arch support.

#CommissionsEarned

4. WALKHERO PLANTAR FASCIITIS INSOLES

WalkHero orthotic insoles with arch support and cushioning for everyday foot comfort

What makes it worth considering?

WALKHERO Plantar Fasciitis Insoles combine structured arch support, a deep heel cup, and cushioning in a full-length design intended for everyday footwear.

Why consider it?

• Structured arch support
• Deep heel cup
• Full-length design
• Cushioning for everyday comfort
• Designed for men and women
• Full-length support for everyday footwear

Potential drawback

The structured design may feel firmer than a basic cushioning insole, and the full-length construction requires enough room inside your footwear.

Best suited for

People looking for a full-length insole that combines arch support, heel stability, and cushioning for everyday walking, standing, or work.

#CommissionsEarned

5. SPENCO TOTAL SUPPORT MAX INSOLES

Spenco Total Support Max insoles with structured arch support, heel cushioning and forefoot comfort

What makes it worth considering?

Spenco Total Support Max combines structured arch support with cushioning and additional forefoot support, making it an option to consider for people who want more than basic heel cushioning.

Why consider it?

• Structured arch support
• Added cushioning for everyday comfort
• Forefoot and metatarsal support
• Full-length design
• Designed for everyday and active footwear
• Combines heel, arch, and forefoot support

Potential drawback

The additional structure and cushioning can take up more space inside the shoe, so it may not be ideal for tighter or low-volume footwear.

Best suited for

People looking for a combination of arch support, cushioning, and additional forefoot support for everyday activities.

#CommissionsEarned


HOW TO CHOOSE THE RIGHT INSOLE FOR PLANTAR FASCIITIS

The right insole isn't necessarily the most expensive or the most cushioned. Your foot shape, footwear, daily activities, and personal comfort all matter.

Here are five important factors to consider before choosing an insole.


1. Arch Support

Look for an insole that provides a level of support that feels appropriate for your foot. Firmer or higher arch support isn't automatically better—the right fit should feel supportive without creating uncomfortable pressure.


2. Cushioning

Cushioning can help improve comfort, particularly if you spend long periods walking or standing. Keep in mind that soft cushioning and structural arch support serve different purposes, and some insoles combine both.


3. Shoe Compatibility

Check how much room you have inside your shoes. Full-length or structured insoles may require removing the original shoe liner and can make tighter footwear feel crowded.


4. Your Daily Activities

Think about where and how you'll use the insoles. Someone who stands for hours at work may have different needs from someone looking for additional support during walking, exercise, or occasional use.


5. Comfort & Adjustment

Structured insoles can feel different at first. Follow the manufacturer's instructions and allow time to adjust gradually. If an insole causes significant or persistent discomfort, stop using it and consider professional guidance.

WHICH ONE MAY FIT YOUR NEEDS?

Wise Pick:

Consider PowerStep Pinnacle if:
You're looking for a balance of structured arch support and cushioning for everyday use.


Consider Superfeet Green if:
You prefer firmer, higher-profile arch support and have enough room inside your footwear.


Consider Dr. Scholl's Plantar Fasciitis Orthotics if:
You're looking for a more budget-conscious option with heel cushioning and everyday support.


Consider Walkhero if:
You want a balance of arch support and cushioning for walking and active everyday use.


Consider Spenco Total Support Max if:
You're looking for structured arch support combined with additional cushioning and forefoot support.


Remember: The best option depends on your individual foot shape, footwear, comfort preferences, and needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Supportive insoles may help improve comfort for some people by providing additional arch and heel support and helping distribute pressure across the foot. Results vary, however, and insoles are not a substitute for professional diagnosis or treatment.

It depends on your individual needs and comfort preferences. Softer insoles generally emphasize cushioning, while more structured options provide firmer arch support. Some products, such as the options compared in this guide, combine both support and cushioning.

It depends on the product and your footwear. Many full-length replacement insoles are designed to be used after removing the shoe’s original removable insole. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions and make sure your shoes still fit comfortably without feeling too tight.

Structured insoles may feel noticeably different at first. Some people prefer to increase wear time gradually while their feet adjust. Follow the manufacturer's recommendations and stop using the product if it causes significant or persistent discomfort.

Consider speaking with a qualified healthcare professional if your pain is severe, persistent, worsening, affecting your ability to walk normally, or accompanied by significant swelling, numbness, injury, or other concerning symptoms.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Choosing an insole for plantar fasciitis isn't simply about finding the most expensive option or the one with the most cushioning. The right choice depends on your foot shape, footwear, activity level, comfort preferences, and the type of support you need.


Among the options in this guide, PowerStep Pinnacle is our featured pick for shoppers looking for a balance of structured arch support and cushioning for everyday footwear. 

Superfeet Green may be worth considering if you prefer firmer, higher-profile support, while Dr. Scholl's offers a more budget-conscious option. WalkHero and Spenco Total Support Max provide additional alternatives depending on your preferred fit, cushioning, and support.


Whichever option you choose, make sure it fits your footwear comfortably and follow the manufacturer's instructions. If foot pain is severe, persistent, worsening, or affecting your ability to walk normally, consider speaking with a qualified healthcare professional.

🏆 CHECK POWERSTEP PINNACLE ON AMAZON →

AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE

Five Stars Finds participates in affiliate programs, including the Amazon Associates Program. Some links on this page are affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you make a qualifying purchase through them, at no additional cost to you.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Our goal is to provide useful product information and comparisons to help readers make informed purchasing decisions.

MEDICAL DISCLAIMER

The information provided by Five Stars Finds is for general informational and educational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.


Product information and comparisons on this page should not replace advice from a qualified healthcare professional. Individual needs and results may vary.


If you have persistent, severe, or worsening foot pain, or concerns about a medical condition, consult a qualified healthcare professional before relying on any product for symptom management.